Textbook Question
The chiral BINAP ligand shown in Figure 8-8 contains no asymmetric carbon atoms. Explain how this ligand is chiral.
5. Chirality
Chirality
3:24 minutesProblem 15a,b
Textbook Question
Draw three-dimensional representations of the following compounds. Which have asymmetric carbon atoms? Which have no asymmetric carbons but are chiral anyway? Use your models for parts (a) through (d) and any others that seem unclear.
(a) 
(b) 
Verified step by step guidance1
Step 1: Understand the problem. You are tasked with determining the three-dimensional structure of the given compounds, identifying asymmetric carbon atoms (if any), and determining whether the compounds are chiral even in the absence of asymmetric carbons. Chirality and asymmetry are key concepts here.
Step 2: Analyze compound (a) ClHC═C═CHCl (1,3-dichloropropadiene). Draw the structure of the compound, noting that it contains two double bonds in a conjugated system. The chlorine atoms are attached to the first and third carbons. Consider the spatial arrangement of the substituents around the double bonds, as double bonds restrict rotation.
Step 3: Determine if compound (a) has asymmetric carbons. An asymmetric carbon is a carbon atom bonded to four different groups. In this compound, all carbons are part of the double bonds, and none are bonded to four different groups. Therefore, there are no asymmetric carbons. Next, assess chirality. A molecule can be chiral without asymmetric carbons if it lacks a plane of symmetry and is non-superimposable on its mirror image. Evaluate the spatial arrangement of the substituents to determine chirality.
Step 4: Analyze compound (b) ClHC═C═CHCH3 (1-chlorobuta-1,2-diene). Draw the structure of the compound, noting that it contains two double bonds in an allene system. The chlorine atom is attached to the first carbon, and the methyl group is attached to the fourth carbon. Consider the unique geometry of allenes, where the two π-bonds are orthogonal to each other, creating a three-dimensional structure.
Step 5: Determine if compound (b) has asymmetric carbons. As with compound (a), check if any carbon is bonded to four different groups. In this case, none of the carbons meet this criterion. Next, assess chirality. Due to the orthogonal arrangement of the π-bonds in allenes, the substituents on the terminal carbons can create a chiral center even in the absence of asymmetric carbons. Evaluate the substituents to confirm chirality.
Verified video answer for a similar problem:This video solution was recommended by our tutors as helpful for the problem above
Video duration:
3mWas this helpful?
Key Concepts
Here are the essential concepts you must grasp in order to answer the question correctly.
Asymmetric Carbon Atoms
Asymmetric carbon atoms, or chiral centers, are carbon atoms that are bonded to four different substituents. This unique arrangement allows for non-superimposable mirror images, known as enantiomers. Identifying these centers is crucial for determining the chirality of a compound, which affects its optical activity and reactivity.
Recommended video:
Guided course
01:44
The difference between atomic numbers and atomic mass.
Chirality Without Asymmetric Carbons
Some molecules can exhibit chirality even without asymmetric carbon atoms due to their geometric arrangement. This can occur in compounds with restricted rotation around double bonds or in cyclic structures, leading to non-superimposable mirror images. Understanding this concept is essential for recognizing chiral behavior in various organic compounds.
Recommended video:
Guided course
05:41Understanding Other Chiral Atoms
Three-Dimensional Molecular Representation
Three-dimensional representations of molecules, such as ball-and-stick models or space-filling models, help visualize the spatial arrangement of atoms. These models are vital for understanding molecular geometry, bond angles, and the overall shape of the molecule, which are important for predicting reactivity and interactions in organic chemistry.
Recommended video:
Guided course
07:44Molecular Geometry Explained.
Related Videos
Related Practice